Sunday, August 10, 2008

Masculine Tears


I’ve always found it somehow too complicated for me to understand why men usually tend to avoid crying (especially in public) and hold back their tears. Admittedly, and unlike women, men are usually taught, from an early age, that crying is a girly thing, that tears were meant to fall on the softer cheeks, that men simply don’t cry and accordingly they’re trained not to break into tears in front of others. Growing up with that conviction, men would most likely claim that crying is a sign of vulnerability, an undesired human need; something they intentionally avoid, throughout the course of their lives, in order to preserve their image of mighty manliness.


On the day my uncle died few years back, I kept attentively observing my father, almost feeling the intensity of his grief in the air around me and hoping to see him drop a tear or two over his brother’s death that I thought might help provide him with at least some comfort. But my hopes were shattered every time I looked at him strongly pulling himself together. However, and on that same night, after everyone was gone, I ran accidently into my father, sitting alone in a dim-lighted room, his hands covering his face and a horrifying sound of weeping seemed to shake my world. I, carefully, walked out of that room surprisingly smiling and relieved that my father has finally surrendered to his inner, irresistible urge to cry, and accordingly found some relief through it.


Just last week, on the other hand, I was in a hospital’s waiting area. As I was tediously waiting for my name to be called, a lady with her two children sat next to me. I couldn’t help but to notice the way she furiously scolded her almost five-year-old son every time the poor child cried out loud. Despite the irritated mother’s several attempts, the young boy was annoyingly crying non-stop. Then, as soon as the mother spelled out the magic words; "dear, men don’t cry! Don’t you already know that? You’re a MAN. Only girls cry” and peace finally found its way back into the room.


Whatever be the reason, we all know men just can’t cry (or at least not in front of others). But surely they do cry, probably not to the world, but behind closed doors, to themselves. However, the question remains, why men are burdened to meet the social or cultural expectations by being ‘tough as a rock’? Why men are supposed to shield themselves against all human emotions and avoid those transparent drops to fall down their faces? Why the teary eyes are a source of unforgivable disgrace according to the incomprehensible laws of men’s world? And why men strongly believe that “one who cries is not a man” ?

16 comments:

8bitsofcoffee said...

Great post msh'Allah :)
You said:
"men would most likely claim that crying is a sign of vulnerability"
Is it not so for both genders that is?
That's why people tend to avoid crying in public. It's not disgraceful, just private.
It's true what you're saying about men though. When my father lost his mother, he was eerily composed, to the point where I got quite worried about him just like you did with your father. And the same thing happened; I walked over to his room to see how he was doing and found him crying. I was utterly confused, I have never seen him this way and wished I could walk over to him and give him a hug, but I knew that as soon as he sensed me approaching he would wipe his tears and ask how I was.
Fathers' rock, don't they? :D
By the way, you have a wonderful way with words msh'Allah :)

A Global Citizen said...

8bitsofcoffee,

Crying is not always a sign of vulnerability, at least not to everyone and not in every situation. I mean crying shouldn't be associated to sadness or depression. A proud father, for instance, would still resist the urge to cry the happy tears when seeing his son/daughter earning a college degree.

Besides, it's a fact that not a lot of people (from both genders) feel comfortable crying in public. But, what I meant was, crying in front of your best friend, a close family-member, a loved one, someone you trust and value is totally acceptable and normal (or so I think!)

Still, men prefer to isolate themselves completely in order to accept their normal human need to cry.

Btw, thanks for the sweet words. Always a pleasure reading your comments. :)

8bitsofcoffee said...

"A proud father, for instance, would still resist the urge to cry the happy tears when seeing his son/daughter earning a college degree"
I forgot all about happy tears. Haven't had them for the longest time.
I do see your point of view :)

Khadija said...

Lovely post... I read somewhere that little boys who are taught to resist crying grow up to be men who can't express their feelings. Don't know how true it is, my psych knowledge is far from expert. But it's worth thinking about.. what do you think?

It's interesting that crying is the most basic form of communication yet, as we learn to manipulate language to meet our communication demands, crying is relegated to the private, the shameful... hmmm...

A Global Citizen said...

Khadija,

Yes, there have been some speculations that younger boys whom are taught to avoid crying, eventually grow up to have some sort of a difficulty expressing their feelings.

Frankly, I believe that theory could be somehow true. I mean think about it, if sons are demanded by their parents to be 'tough' and sometimes emotionless, do you think they would eventually grow up allowing the sensitive, emotional part of them to surface?

Khadija said...

mmm... true.

cookiesobsession said...

Big Boys, Don't cry !
i do cry profusely if the situation demands. i have had hudnreds of chances to cry my pains out. it is internal shower done in the most visible and conspicous ways. great hearts cry, or i would say all good hearts cry. we would have good times in our life if, as you said, were given the freedom to cry out. it is a pity that man don't cry, crying and laughing men live longer and healthier life. it is hipocracy that makes many men not cry. they know it is great to be crying. poor creatures they eat away all thier pains and feign themselves to be strong or manly. if women cry, men too have to, basically these two are not at all different. cry and cry your way to good life and healthy times. =] great post !

Crimson Shimmer said...

hmmmm: wot an interesting post.
i could really ramble here but i'll try to cut short.
1st: from a human's perspective, i think that crying is as healing, therapeutic and necessary as laughing.
2nd: from a man's perspective, let me tell you we have it hard. its not primarily related to the upbringing, the truth is the society, the media and the westernised culture that binds it. most women are too glad too quickly to insult men, to make men feel small when they cry, even display a tad bit of emotion. this is todays world. men have little choice but to avoid this dampening at all cost. something a woman may not understand. i think this is what the truth boils down to, and it would be lovely if it were different but at the end of the day, the choices are in our hands. for women and men alike. i think this is a journey all men must undertake, im glad to say that i can cry as easily as i laugh and now that i understand its wisdom would neva eva give up the beauty in its ability for anything. eva :)

Broken Wing said...

oh men! there are many myths about men and their emotions

Although both men and women cry, the sexes process and express emotions differently, one of them being crying.

why do men tend to hide their emotions? blame their male brain

throughout time men have been the stronger species, the protectors, the caregivers. Crying was and for many men still is a sign of weakness!

Great Post, Global

A Global Citizen said...

@ cookiesobsession

Looks like we both agree on that both men and women shouldn't be deprived of the healing, soothing power of crying.

@ crimson shimmer

It is quite interesting to get the straight-forward opinion of a man on this sensitive issue. I'm glad to learn that not all men are controlled by the idea that crying is shameful. And that some of them do actually surrender to this healing human need.

@ Broken Wing

I see your point & I quite agree with you. To a man, appearing to be strong and dependable obviously beats the emotional side of every human being.

ren_crow said...

Well as a man I'm also guilty of not crying. The logic here is that if women are the ones who will cry and get all emotional then there has to be someone who won't, in order to counterbalance the grief experienced by these people.

Culture Shock said...

In a couple, one needs to lean on the other, so one cries, and the other comforts. Everyone gets their turn.

Children cry a lot, about everything, when they don't get what they want for example. That is not crying due to sadness, or pain, or grief but to try to get what you want. Should they be told not to cry? Who knows? But when a child, or any person cries, truly cries, then hug them, and be their rock.

May we all blessed with solid shoulders to cry on, sympathetic ears to listen, and wise voices to comfort. In and out.

I appreciate your thoughts.

A Global Citizen said...

@ ren_crow

Oh com'on. let's put the whiny, crying-all-the-time women aside, but aren't men humans too? (The answer to this question should be interesting :D )

@ culture shock

Amin to that!

A pleasure reading your comment! :)

Khadija said...

now really ren_crow...!that's just such macho mumbo garbledy goo... global i'm eager to see the answer to your question too :p

Khadija said...
This post has been removed by the author.
His Sweetheart said...

Well put hun!!
That's something I have always wondered about!!

The answer is us. It's raising men up since their childhood that "he who cries is not a man"!!

We Saudis follow that mostly. Simply because we always boost of how manly our guys are. They start from the scratch and help raising up families!!

It is wrong I must admit. Crying is one way that helps us to relieve in bad times!! Guys are humans just like gals. There shouldn't be any role or a tradition thingie that stops it just because they are MEN!!